Archive for the ‘Special Relationship’ Category

No Relief – Issue of Town’s Liability Regarding Condition of High School Baseball Field for the Jury (MA)

October 19, 2015

Murray v. Town of Hudson (Massachusetts)

A relief pitcher for a high school baseball team injured his knee while warming up in the visiting team bullpen.  He filed a lawsuit against the town that maintained the park at which the baseball field was located, alleging that the injury was caused by the town’s negligence and its wanton and reckless conduct in allowing the visiting team to use a dangerous bullpen.  The town filed a motion for summary judgment arguing that the negligence claim was barred by the Massachusetts recreational use statute, and that the evidence did not support a finding of wanton or reckless conduct.  The trial court granted the defendant’s motion, and the pitcher appealed.

(more…)

Unreasonable Eviction – Colorado Supreme Court Finds That Hotel Owed a Duty to Evicted Drunk Guests (CO)

May 6, 2015

Westin Operator, LLC v. Groh (Colorado)

The issue raised by the case (an issue of first impression for the Supreme Court of Colorado) was: “What duty of care, if any, does a hotel owe to a guest during a lawful eviction?”

Following a late night out in downtown Denver, the plaintiff brought a group of friends back to a hotel room she had rented at the hotel operated by the defendant.  Thereafter, security guards from the hotel confronted the group about the noise level coming from their room, and the hotel eventually evicted them from the premises.  Plaintiff and her group were evicted “even though [they] advised the guards that they were drunk and could not drive.”  One of the members of the party asked if he could stay in the lobby to wait for a taxicab because it was cold outside, but the security guarded refused.  Plaintiff and six others got into plaintiff’s car, with a drunk driver behind the wheel.  Fifteen miles later, the car rear-ended another car.  The resulting crash killed a third party and left the plaintiff in a persistent vegetative state with traumatic brain injuries.

(more…)