Archive for the ‘Movie’ Category

Front Row Seats – Woman Injured by Stampede in Overcrowded Movie Theater; Crowd Control Liability for the Jury (NY)

August 27, 2015

Sachar v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc. (New York)

Plaintiff was escorting a group of teenagers to see a free screening of a movie.   Plaintiff’s group was directed to an upper level to find seat, but was then told to turn around and go downstairs.  As the group was returning, there was a sudden stampede of people rushing from behind.  The assistant manager of the movie theater confirmed that there appeared to have been a stampede, and an employee of the movie studio that produced the movie testified that the event was overbooked to ensure that the theater was filled to capacity.

As a result of the stampede, plaintiff was pushed forward and she was “hurled in the air,” suffering personal injury.  Plaintiff filed a lawsuit against both the movie theater and the movie studio.  The defendants filed motions for summary judgment, which were granted by the trial court.  Plaintiff filed a motion to reargue the motions, and upon re-argument, the trial court denied the defendants’ motion.  The defendants then appealed.

On appeal, the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court affirmed the decision.  The Court explained that “[u]nder the circumstances presented, involving the deliberate overbooking of a theater for a free film screening, defendants were required to show that they took adequate crowd control measures to address the foreseeable risks to those attending in order to meet their prima facie burden of demonstrating entitlement to summary judgment.”  However, the defendants failed to present evidence that adequate crowd control measure were in place at the time of the incident.  The Court also stated that “the deposition testimony also creates an issue of fact as to [the movie studio’s] specific security duties, as sponsors of the event, at the screening.”