Archive for the ‘Locker Room’ Category

Headline: Water is Wet – Defendant Wins Health Club Locker Room Slip and Fall Case (OH)

April 28, 2015

Daher v. Bally’s Total Fitness (Ohio)

The plaintiff was a member of the defendant’s health club.  On a visit to the club, she slipped and fell on a wet surface in the locker room.  Plaintiff filed an action against the defendant alleging negligent maintenance of the premises.  The defendant filed a motion to summary judgment based upon the “open & obvious doctrine” and the contract signed by members containing clear and unequivocal release language.  The plaintiff did not oppose the motion, and the trial court granted the defendants’ motion.  Despite not having opposed the motion, the plaintiff appealed the ruling.

On appeal, the Court of Appeals of Ohio affirmed the trial court ruling.  First, the Court explained that despite the fact that the plaintiff had not opposed the motion, the defendant was not entitled to summary judgment absent proof that such judgment was appropriate.  Looking at the evidence, the Court concluded that “the wet condition of the locker room near the pool area was open and obvious.”  Plaintiff argued that the doctrine should not apply because “there was no alternative route or other means available for [her] to protect herself from the hazard posed by the wet floor,” but the Court was unconvinced. (more…)