Archive for the ‘Indiana’ Category

Show’s Over – Indemnity Dispute Between State Fair and Equipment Lessor Regarding Collapsed Stage Continues (IN)

May 29, 2015

In re Indiana State Fair Litigation (Indiana)
(one Judge dissenting)

This case arises from a collapsed stage at a state fair in August of 2011, which caused several deaths and injuries.  The issue was whether the stage equipment supplier (Mid-America Sound [“Mid-America”]) was entitled to indemnification from the event operator (the Indiana State Fair Commission [“Commission”]) based on the terms and conditions of the typical course of business between them.

Dating back to the mid-1990s, the Commission leased temporary roof structures and other equipment from Mid-America to use for outdoor concerts on property operated by the Commission.  During the last ten years of their relationship, the parties followed the same procedure with regard to the equipment leasing.  Mid-America delivered the equipment before the event and then later returned to pick up the equipment after the event.  When it picked up the equipment, Mid-America would sign contracts for the rented items and submit the contracts to the Commission.  The Commission audited each contract to make sure it conformed to the agreement of the parties and then issued payment.

(more…)

Minor Dies During Motorcycle Race at IMS

August 31, 2010

United States Grand Prix Racers Union (Indiana)
(13-year-old young died when he was run over by a 12-year-old co-participant.)

As recently reported in the USA Today, a minor amateur motorcycle rider died this past weekend at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway. The race was a private event sanctioned by the U.S. Grand Prix Racers Union (“USGPRU”).  A spokesman for the USGPRU said that it will discuss ways to make the sport safer. According to the USGPRU’s website, a memorial fund has been established in honor of the deceased minor.

NOTE: The minor release form used by the USGPRU as posted on its website is attached. Is it very short and basic. While the incident occurred in Indiana, the sanctioning body appears to be from Virginia, and the deceased minor was Washington. Indiana has a statute which allows a minor to become partially emancipated for the purposes of filling out the necessary contracts and waiver and release forms in order to participate in motorsports activities. We did not see any information to indicate whether or not the statute was employed for participants in this event.

Golf Course Backs Out of Liability to Injured Golfer

July 6, 2008

Parsons v. Arrowhead Golf (Indiana)
(Court Holds that Golf Course Owed No Duty to Prevent a Golfer’s Back Injury Suffered When He Stepped Out of Golf Cart.)

The defendant managed an 18-hole golf course where the plaintiff was playing golf. The plaintiff stepped off of a golf cart, landed “straight-legged” and immediately experienced lower back pain. The plaintiff stated that the drop was four to twelve inches deep, and that he had not noticed this irregularity on the grounds during his past years of golfing experience on this course. Plaintiff had golfed here once per week for over two years. The manager of the course had regularly inspected the grounds for dangerous conditions and moved walking paths as necessary to ensure that they did not become worn out. In this particular instance, the manager had placed stone where the plaintiff was injured. Plaintiff alleged that the defendant had failed to take reasonable safety measures by negligently maintaining the premises and failing to warn him about the danger. The trial court granted summary judgment in favor of the defendant based on assumption of the risk, and the plaintiff appealed.

(more…)

A Bounce in Their Step

July 9, 2007

National Mutual Insurance v. Curtis (Indiana)
(Trampoline Accident Victim Sued Homeowners’ Insurer for Declaratory Relief; Insurer Cited Trampoline Exclusion, But court Found Exclusion to Be Ambiguous; Insurer Owed Duty)

The plaintiff was seriously injured while attending a graduation party at the home of the Curtises. During the party, he was injured while using a trampoline. The plaintiff filed a lawsuit against the Curtises for his injuries, and he later amended the complaint to add National Mutual Insurance Company as a defendant, seeking a declaration that the Curtises’ policy provided liability coverage for his injuries. National Mutual declined coverage, citing a trampoline exclusion found in a supplement attached to the main policy. The lower court granted the plaintiff’s summary judgment, determining that the policy provided coverage, and National Mutual appealed.

(more…)