Archive for the ‘Guns’ Category

Bad Aim – Checking Out a Friend’s Firearm in Your Garage is Not a Recreational Activity (OH)

July 28, 2015

Lovegrove v. Stapleton (Ohio)

The plaintiff and the defendant were both experienced gunman who shared a common interest in competitive shooting.  Plaintiff and defendant participated together in a Tuesday night shooting league, and they would sometimes go to shooting ranges together on weekends.  In the summer of 2012, plaintiff drove to the defendant’s home to have the defendant notarize some paperwork for him.  Plaintiff brought his new gun with him, knowing that defendant would likely want to check out it out, which, as the evidence established, is something that happens often in the culture of the competitive shooting community.

Before entering defendant’s garage, plaintiff removed the magazine from the gun.  In the garage, he removed the gun from the holster on his waistband, checked the chamber, and set the gun on a workbench.  Defendant notarized plaintiff’s paperwork and then checked out the gun “dry-firing” it multiple times.  Defendant’s children came into the garage a couple of time, but were sent back into the house for their own safety.

Defendant stepped into the house to check on his wife, who was in the backyard.  Plaintiff picked up his paperwork and his gun, and he put the magazine back in the gun.  Since no round was chambered, he could not put on the gun’s safety.  Plaintiff turned around and saw defendant’s children standing in front of him wanting to show him a trophy.  Defendant placed the gun back on the workbench and told the children he would put his things back in his truck and then come inside.  Plaintiff ushered the children back into the house and closed the door.  As plaintiff was turning around he heard the gun go off.  The defendant had returned, picked up the gun from the workbench, and fired the gun.  The bullet hit the workbench and ricocheted, hitting plaintiff in the abdomen.

A year later, plaintiff filed a lawsuit against the defendant alleging that the defendant acted negligently and recklessly in shooting the gun.  The defendant filed a motion for summary judgment, claiming that plaintiff was engaged in a recreational activity and that primary assumption of risk precluded plaintiff’s negligence claim.  Defendant also contended that he had not acted recklessly.  The trial court granted defendant’s motion, and plaintiff appealed.
(more…)